Exquisite Creatures | Crystal Bridges
Creating content strategy, messaging, and copy for Crystal Bridges’ most-attended exhibition ever
In March 2024, Crystal Bridges Museum of American Art opened Exquisite Creatures, an exhibition of 3D artworks made of preserved animal, plant, and mineral specimens by the artist and naturalist Christopher Marley.
My team was responsible for creating the marketing messaging, ad copy, and overall content strategy for the exhibition. After spending 2023 hiring staff and adapting to an institutional restructure, we were ready for a chance to prove that actual content strategy practice could move the needle on sales and attendance.
By the time Exquisite Creatures closed at the end of July, it was clear we’d succeeded: the exhibition was Crystal Bridges’ most attended show in its thirteen-year history.
Read on for the story of how we pulled off the historic win, or jump straight to the results to see what we created for yourself.
The Challenge
To get results, my team had to figure out how to get the right message to the right people. Our last few major exhibitions had underperformed relative to our ambitions, either meeting targets or just missing them, so the pressure was on.
Our focus was ad copy and messaging, with a goal of creating creative concepts and text to drive ticket sales and attendance.
Thankfully, the Marketing Strategy & Operations team in our department had just leveled up their audience research and targeting methods. As with past exhibitions, our main targets were local and regional residents—folks who either lived in Northwest Arkansas or were within day trip distance. But we had the additional goal of targeting three clear audiences with data-backed motivations:
Families & Enrichment Seekers
Families looking for enriching, entertaining experiences that kids would enjoy while gaining something.
A core audience for the museum.
Needed to be shown that EC was both fun and educational—as well as worth the time.
The main decision-makers here were working moms; tech-savvy young professionals and parents who kept a busy calendar and an active family. They were smart, driven, and wanted the best for their families.
Trendsetters & Experience Seekers
Folks looking for the latest and greatest cultural experiences, with an eye to being able to share and brag online about their adventures.
Tended to be younger, gayer, more likely to be single or childless, and very plugged into the local arts & culture scene. Mainly looking for fantastic experiences they could be immersed in and share about socially.
A more aspirational audience for us, but one that clearly turned out in force when the stars aligned with their interests.
Nature Lovers & Sanctuary Seekers
An older, values-driven audience made up of sanctuary-seekers and folks looking to connect with nature and art.
This audience cared about sustainability, taking time for self-care, and really experiencing the natural world.
Likely older, retired, and living in nearby Fayetteville (whoch hsd a reputation for being a much trendier, hippie-friendly college town than corporate Bentonville.)
The Method
So, to thread our three-sided messaging needle, we brought out a process I had developed over the course of our last exhibition, Annie Leibovitz at Work.
For Annie (my first exhibition project of this scale as lead writer from start to finish), I had worked with the Interpretation Content Specialist assigned to the exhibition to create messaging that was more dynamic and energetic than anything we’d put out in my tenure at the museum. And we saw the results with a marked uptick over the spring show’s attendance.
In the past, a single copywriter assigned to an exhibition (for a time, the institution’s only copywriter) would brainstorm selling points with the full department in a single sprint/workshop and then develop a complete messaging framework and campaign copy package.
After some editing and stakeholder review, it would then go out into the world as finished creative (using visuals from the assigned designer.)
For Annie, by contrast, I’d worked collaboratively with the exhibition’s interpretation SME over a series of long evenings, teasing out pillar ideas and phrases from her casual descriptions of Leibovitz’s work.
From those work sessions, we were able to connect specific messages with channels and audiences. We already knew some of the big elements of the ad plan (such as the full page ad going in Conde Nast’s Vogue, Vanity Fair, and Architectural Digest), so we pulled out key ideas like the pairing “iconic” and “daring” to contrast Leibovitz’s well-known works with her new, must-see commissions.
My ad for Annie Leibovitz at Work that ran in Vogue, Vanity Fair, and Architectural Digest.
I wanted that same level of specificity and strategic writing for EC, but I also wanted to produce it consistently.
I’m a big fan of Brain Traffic’s Content Strategy Quad that puts workflow and process as the foundation of good editorial substance.
So, to help us get out of the “Wild West” days of relying on a solo writer for each project who may or may not have strategy experience, I developed a process rooted in design thinking that helped the whole team connect to audiences and develop great content.
In that process, an assigned copywriter still takes on the brunt of drafting the project’s content (in this case, me), but they don’t start from selling points or a blank page.
Instead, I facilitated workshops and messaging sprints that built empathy for the audience’s perspective.
An actual whiteboard from our “messaging sprint”.
As a team, we systematically reviewed each audience persona, imagined ourselves in their shoes, and described the words, phrases, and ideas that we would need to believe or respond to in order to attend the exhibition and move through the sales funnel.
As patterns emerged, I’d capture them on a dedicated board and organize messages into core pillars, group audiences that would respond to similar messages, and identify content formats and types that suited those messages especially well.
From there, the copywriter would meet with other teams to check patterns against their own insights (e.g., what PR & Social Media had seen as story/pitch opportunities, what Creative was developing on the visual front, what Marketing Strategy saw in the larger dataset).
They’d develop a messaging framework and codify how ads and messages would evolve throughout the campaign’s lifespan, how phrasing would need to be adjusted per persona, and what channels and content formats would work best for each audience and funnel stage.
A back-and-forth of internal and stakeholder reviews would happen, and our findings would be shared out across the whole department for alignment.
In short, by starting with data, empathy, and a clear process, we turned copywriters into strategists. And the quality of the work proved the extra time was worth it.
The Results
Over 114,000 visitors and half a million in sales
A general-audience print ad.
After all the edits settled and the finished creative started rolling out into the world, it was clear we had succeeded at what we set out to do. Each audience (or combo) had tailored content that spoke to them, and the guests (and ticket sales) started rolling in.
For general audiences, we leaned into the visuals and captured a fun, energetic vibe with playful invitations. “Flutter”, “crawl”, and “scurry” made their way onto signs, billboards, digital ads, and print promotions where indiscriminate eyeballs would see the message. And direct mail, a longtime favorite for our major exhibition campaigns, helped us reach local audiences throughout the area.
One of many digital ads aimed at “Immersive Miguel”, our experience-seeker segment.
For the experience seekers, we went direct and wove in descriptive language such as “dazzling displays” and unexpected comparisons between rubies, sapphires, and the gem-like colors of scarab beetles.
Wherever we could, we highlighted the concrete sensory details and experiential aspects of the show. We promoted cocktail tours and related events in email round-ups and advertorials, and used sponsored content to get the exhibition included in the same channels people already looked to for things to do.
The social media team was able to take our suggested content themes and direction and add their own spin to create highlight reels and walkthroughs on Instagram that leaned into surprise, the unexpected, and the sparkle of seeing something unique for yourself.
A digital billboard for “Techie Tina”, our STEAM-minded parent audience.
The back of our direct mailer, sent to households throughout NWA.
For families and those looking for pure fun, we leaned into the dualities of these creatures that “fascinate and frighten”, or seem “weird and wonderful” while they saw art that “informs and inspires.”
Kids got to get excited about weird (but cool) bugs, and parents knew they’d actually learn something science-y in the process. We especially used PeachJar, a favorite of local school districts, to get camps, family days, and more educational events in front of parents when they were planning their kids’ activities.
A billboard for “Sanctuary Sage”, our values-driven audience that wanted peace, nature, and to experience something in line with their beliefs.
Lastly, for the sanctuary seekers, we leaned into language that highlighted nature, its grandeur, and that the show allows us to connect with the natural world. We sought placements in regional publications that advertised a lot of outdoor tourism, promoted connected artist talks and demos, and highlighted the ethical and sustainable practices used by the artist to help alleviate concerns.
And best of all: it worked!
We quickly saw flocks of guests (and ticket sales) roll in, blowing past our attendance goal a bit over halfway through the exhibition’s run. The final count put attendance at over 114,000, with over $500,000 in ticket sales.
Since members saw the show for free, and most on-site visitors also bought something in the coffee shop, or in the museum store, or also got tickets to a paid event, this was easily our most successful exhibition from a business standpoint in years.
Clearly, that level of success requires the work of teams and divisions across the institution, from Guest Services to Data Strategy, but I can’t help but to see a clear connection between our improved strategy practice and the marked jump in sales that went with it.
Which is why we’ve since used it for messaging around our art, technology, and wellness collaboration with Jewel, our newest outdoor light experience by Klip Collective, our fall exhibition Knowing the West, and even the general awareness campaign we’re rolling out in late 2024.